Wednesday, September 25, 2013
Of Mice and Men Claims and Evidence
I agree with George's decision. The debate did not impact we still agree that George should have killed Lennie. As mentioned in many points displayed Curley would have hurt Lennie then George ever did by shooting him.
OMAM Claims and Evidence
We would argue this topic in favor in George killing Lennie. No, it did not change our opinions because we strongly believe that George was in the right for killing Lennie out of love not of hate. Some textual evidence for that George killed Lennie out of mercy not for murder is, " s'spose they lock him up an' strap him down and put him in a cage. That ain't not good"
Mental health
For the pro argument, the best argument was explained how if George did not kill him, Lennie would have ended up in a mental hospital or for tired by Curley. Lennie died happy and calm unlike what would have happened if Curley killed him. "..Curley's still mad about his hand. An' s'pose they lock him up an' strap him down and put him in a cage.." explains how his death would have not been the same if George did not kill him.
For the com arguments, the argument that explained how shooting Lennie would not have solved anything that they should have faced their problems and work through them. "..I'll fin' a cave an' I'll live there there so I won't be no more trouble to George" displays how there were other options instead of just killing him.
We feel that it was better for George to kill Lennie that no one would have helped him get better that he would have died anyways.
Ashley Parcher
James Brady
Aubree Lujan
For the com arguments, the argument that explained how shooting Lennie would not have solved anything that they should have faced their problems and work through them. "..I'll fin' a cave an' I'll live there there so I won't be no more trouble to George" displays how there were other options instead of just killing him.
We feel that it was better for George to kill Lennie that no one would have helped him get better that he would have died anyways.
Ashley Parcher
James Brady
Aubree Lujan
Infographics
We learned the symptoms of some mental disabilities such as anxiety and depression. The strategies that we really liked was how they incorporated graphics with the information, it kept it interesting. We liked the designs that were exhibited.
Lindsay, Brianna, Trighton, Michael
Of mice and men claims and evidence
Cassie, Emma, Ashley
Best positive post: if George had not killed him, Lennie would have ended up in a mental hospital or being tortured by Curley. Also, Lennie died happy, if he had been killed by Curley, he would not have died happy.
Best Negative post:
I think shooting Lennie was a terrible idea, because it made their problems vanish instead of facing them and working through them. George had the option to face the men and tell them that Lennie had mental disabilities that prevent him from knowing what he is doing at times.
We all agree that it was good for George to end Lennie's life because he did not want Curley to torture him. Curley stated "I'm gonna shoot refutes outa that bastard my self, even if I only got one hand. I'm gonna get 'im"( Steinbeck 98). It was very hard for George to kill Lennie, "the hand shook violently, but his face set and his hands steady" ( Steinbeck 106). George ended Lennie's life in order for him to die happy.
Best positive post: if George had not killed him, Lennie would have ended up in a mental hospital or being tortured by Curley. Also, Lennie died happy, if he had been killed by Curley, he would not have died happy.
Best Negative post:
I think shooting Lennie was a terrible idea, because it made their problems vanish instead of facing them and working through them. George had the option to face the men and tell them that Lennie had mental disabilities that prevent him from knowing what he is doing at times.
We all agree that it was good for George to end Lennie's life because he did not want Curley to torture him. Curley stated "I'm gonna shoot refutes outa that bastard my self, even if I only got one hand. I'm gonna get 'im"( Steinbeck 98). It was very hard for George to kill Lennie, "the hand shook violently, but his face set and his hands steady" ( Steinbeck 106). George ended Lennie's life in order for him to die happy.
Mental Health Infographics
We found it surprising that 50% of the IDs with mental disabilities kill themselves. As well as that 50% age 14 up drop school if they have a mental disability or even that only a third of people with mental disabilities get treatment.
Mental health info graphics
We all thought that it was almost unbelievable that only 100billion dollars is spent toward mentally ill people and that 1 in 17 Americans have a mental disability. We liked the percentages, charts, and cartoon-like drawing that made it visually appealing to the reader.
Katie Dodge, Vincent Vaishville, Sierra Pell
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)